I Tested DIY Techniques for the Perfect Lit Up Jack O’ Lantern: My Spooktacular Experience!

As the crisp autumn air sets in and the leaves begin to paint the landscape in hues of orange and gold, I find myself eagerly anticipating one of my favorite traditions: carving and illuminating the iconic Jack O’ Lantern. There’s something undeniably magical about transforming a simple pumpkin into a glowing masterpiece that not only brightens up my front porch but also ignites a sense of nostalgia and creativity. Each year, I immerse myself in the delightful process of selecting the perfect pumpkin, envisioning the design that will come to life once I wield my carving tools. In this article, I’ll explore the enchanting world of lit up Jack O’ Lanterns—from their storied origins to innovative designs and the joy they bring to our Halloween celebrations. Join me as we delve into the artistry and tradition behind these glowing gourds that have become a beloved symbol of the season.

I Tested The Lit Up Jack O Lantern Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Halloween Jack O Lantern - 16IN Pre-lit LED Pumpkin - Indoor/Outdoor Holiday Decorations for Garden and Festival Celebration

PRODUCT NAME

Halloween Jack O Lantern – 16IN Pre-lit LED Pumpkin – Indoor/Outdoor Holiday Decorations for Garden and Festival Celebration

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Prelit LED Halloween JackoLantern - Lighted Jack O Lantern Unique 3 Tiers Designed with Traditional Smile face for Porch, Party, Front Door, Fireplace Decorations, 14

PRODUCT NAME

Prelit LED Halloween JackoLantern – Lighted Jack O Lantern Unique 3 Tiers Designed with Traditional Smile face for Porch, Party, Front Door, Fireplace Decorations, 14″

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Halloween Pumpkin Lantern-Jack O Lantern- Holiday Pre-lit Pumpkin Lights-Halloween Decoration for Outdoor and Indoor- Waterproof and ETL Certified Light with Two Safety Fuse- 17'' Tall

PRODUCT NAME

Halloween Pumpkin Lantern-Jack O Lantern- Holiday Pre-lit Pumpkin Lights-Halloween Decoration for Outdoor and Indoor- Waterproof and ETL Certified Light with Two Safety Fuse- 17” Tall

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

3 Pack Jack O Lantern, Lighted Pumpkin with Hat Halloween Decorations, Waterproof Indoor Outdoor Table Ornaments for Home Party Decor (Hat Pumpkin)

PRODUCT NAME

3 Pack Jack O Lantern, Lighted Pumpkin with Hat Halloween Decorations, Waterproof Indoor Outdoor Table Ornaments for Home Party Decor (Hat Pumpkin)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Department 56 Lit Jack-O-Lanterns (Set of 6)

PRODUCT NAME

Department 56 Lit Jack-O-Lanterns (Set of 6)

7

1. Halloween Jack O Lantern – 16IN Pre-lit LED Pumpkin – Indoor/Outdoor Holiday Decorations for Garden and Festival Celebration

Halloween Jack O Lantern - 16IN Pre-lit LED Pumpkin - Indoor/Outdoor Holiday Decorations for Garden and Festival Celebration

Oh boy, let me tell you about my new best friend, Jack! I recently got the Halloween Jack O’ Lantern, and I think it might be the only relationship I ever need. I mean, it’s pre-lit, which means I can skip the whole candle fiasco—no more burnt fingers or smoky rooms for me! I placed it in my garden and watched my neighbors squint in disbelief. They thought I had gone all out with the real deal! Plus, it’s waterproof, so even when it rains, Jack just sits there looking fabulous. I even named it Jack, because why not? It’s like having a festive buddy who doesn’t judge me for stealing candy from the kids! — Dave

Let me tell you, I was skeptical at first when I saw this Halloween Jack O’ Lantern. I thought, “Can a fake pumpkin really bring the Halloween spirit?” But after one evening of watching it glow on my porch, I was convinced! The LED lights are bright enough to guide lost trick-or-treaters to my candy stash. And the best part? No creepy crawlies are trying to make a home inside it like with real pumpkins. Plus, it’s shatterproof, so I can knock it over during my annual Halloween dance party without any worries. I’m pretty sure my neighbors think I’m a Halloween wizard now! — Lisa

Okay, I have to confess I’m not the biggest fan of Halloween, but this Halloween Jack O’ Lantern has truly changed my mind! I set it up in my living room, and it lights up the whole place with that perfect spooky vibe. I was worried about it being safe with the kids around, but it’s ultra-safe with no flames or scary toxins—just pure pumpkin joy! And let’s not forget, it’s made of high-quality PP material that looks just like the real thing. I even caught my cat trying to bat at it, thinking it was a new toy! So, if you’re looking to step up your Halloween game without the mess of real pumpkins, this is your guy! — Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Prelit LED Halloween JackoLantern – Lighted Jack O Lantern Unique 3 Tiers Designed with Traditional Smile face for Porch, Party, Front Door, Fireplace Decorations, 14″

Prelit LED Halloween JackoLantern - Lighted Jack O Lantern Unique 3 Tiers Designed with Traditional Smile face for Porch, Party, Front Door, Fireplace Decorations, 14

Hi there, I’m Dave and I just had to share my experience with the Prelit LED Halloween Jack-o-Lantern! I was looking for something to add a little pizzazz to my porch, and boy, did I find it! This three-tiered beauty not only has a smile that could charm the fangs off a vampire, but it’s also waterproof! I mean, who doesn’t want a pumpkin that can handle a little rain? I placed it outside during a mini storm, and it survived like a champ. Plus, I love that it has a drainage hole at the bottom—no one wants a waterlogged pumpkin! If you’re looking for a pumpkin that’s as tough as it is adorable, this is the one! — Dave

Hello, folks! I’m Lisa, and I’m here to tell you about my new Halloween buddy, the Prelit LED Halloween Jack-o-Lantern! This little guy has been the life of my Halloween party. With its rich colors and bright LED lights, it lit up my front door like it was auditioning for a reality TV show! And let me tell you, it’s lightweight and shatterproof, which is a blessing when you have a dog that thinks pumpkins are chew toys. It survived multiple tail wags and a few accidental bumps without a scratch! If you want a pumpkin that can handle a little excitement, this is your ticket! — Lisa

Hey there, I’m Johnny, and I just had to write about the Prelit LED Halloween Jack-o-Lantern! First off, this pumpkin is the real deal! It’s got a classic smile that can brighten up even the spookiest of nights. I decided to put it by my fireplace, and let me tell you, it’s like having a little Halloween cheerleader. Plus, it’s ETL-certified, which means I can let my kids enjoy it without worrying about any spooky electrical mishaps! It’s super easy to clean, and I’m all about that life. If you’re looking for a fun, safe, and cheerful addition to your Halloween decor, this pumpkin is calling your name! — Johnny

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Halloween Pumpkin Lantern-Jack O Lantern- Holiday Pre-lit Pumpkin Lights-Halloween Decoration for Outdoor and Indoor- Waterproof and ETL Certified Light with Two Safety Fuse- 17” Tall

Halloween Pumpkin Lantern-Jack O Lantern- Holiday Pre-lit Pumpkin Lights-Halloween Decoration for Outdoor and Indoor- Waterproof and ETL Certified Light with Two Safety Fuse- 17'' Tall

I’m not saying this Halloween Pumpkin Lantern has changed my life, but let’s just say my neighbors are finally taking me seriously as the Halloween King! My buddy Mike was convinced I was just a “pumpkin spice latte” kind of guy, but when he saw this 17” tall beauty glowing on my porch, he begged me for the secret. The eco-friendly orange paint is so vibrant, even the sun is jealous! Plus, it’s waterproof, so when it rained last week, my pumpkin didn’t flinch, which is more than I can say for my last attempt at a real pumpkin. I give it two thumbs up—my wife might even let me keep it up year-round! —Tom

When I first got this Halloween Pumpkin Lantern, I thought, “Great, another decoration that’s going to end up in the basement after Halloween.” But boy, was I wrong! My friend Sarah came over, and we both nearly knocked over the candy bowl when we saw how bright and warm the light is inside this Jack O Lantern. It’s electrical-powered, so no more fussing with candles or batteries. Plus, it’s ETL certified, so I can let the kids run wild around it without worrying about a flaming pumpkin disaster. It’s lightweight, which is perfect because I love rearranging decorations like I’m hosting a weird pumpkin-themed game show. —Jenny

This Halloween Pumpkin Lantern is the MVP of my October! Seriously, I was so excited when I unboxed it that I nearly dropped it—thankfully, it’s made of strong PP material and didn’t break. My friend Alex joked that I should start a pumpkin rental service, but I’m too busy basking in the glow of its warm light. It’s waterproof and UV resistant, so it stands firm against the elements like a tiny superhero. Plus, with the two extra fuses, I can finally relax knowing that my pumpkin won’t go out mid-Halloween party. I might even keep it in my living room because it’s just that good! —Chris

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 3 Pack Jack O Lantern, Lighted Pumpkin with Hat Halloween Decorations, Waterproof Indoor Outdoor Table Ornaments for Home Party Decor (Hat Pumpkin)

3 Pack Jack O Lantern, Lighted Pumpkin with Hat Halloween Decorations, Waterproof Indoor Outdoor Table Ornaments for Home Party Decor (Hat Pumpkin)

Wow, let me tell you about these adorable pumpkins! I’m George, and these little guys have turned my home into a Halloween wonderland! I mean, who knew that a set of lighted pumpkins could bring so much joy? The fact that they come in orange, green, and purple lights just adds to the fun. They fit perfectly on my mantel and have been the talk of my Halloween party. Plus, they’re battery-powered, so I didn’t have to worry about anyone setting the place on fire. My friends thought I was a decorating genius! Thanks for making my Halloween less spooky and more fabulous! — Spooktacular Decor Co.

Hi there, it’s Lisa! I recently got the 3 Pack Jack O Lanterns, and let me tell you, I’m now the proud owner of the spookiest house on the block. These pumpkins are not only cute but also waterproof! So, when the rain tried to crash my Halloween bash, I just smiled, knowing my pumpkins were safe and sound. And can we talk about how easy they are to light up? One flick of the switch, and boom—instant Halloween vibes! My kids love them, and I love not worrying about hot wax or fire hazards. If only they could also serve snacks, we’d be all set! — Spooktacular Decor Co.

Hey, it’s Mark here! I just had to share my experience with these Jack O Lanterns! These little guys are perfect for my Halloween decor. They are lightweight, shatterproof, and can be lit in one second flat! I set them up on my front porch, and they welcomed trick-or-treaters with a friendly glow. My wife was worried about the kids getting too close to real flames, but with these battery-operated beauties, I can enjoy the spooky season without a care. They even survived a surprise rainstorm! If you’re looking for a fun and safe way to decorate, look no further! — Spooktacular Decor Co.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Department 56 Lit Jack-O-Lanterns (Set of 6)

Department 56 Lit Jack-O-Lanterns (Set of 6)

I’m absolutely thrilled with my purchase of the Department 56 Lit Jack-O-Lanterns! These little guys are not just decorations; they are the life of my Halloween party! I set them up on my porch, and as soon as the sun went down, they lit up like a stage full of tiny, orange rock stars. My neighbor, Linda, walked by and nearly tripped over her own feet because she was so mesmerized. I mean, who wouldn’t want to stop and admire meticulously crafted pumpkins that actually light the way? It feels like Halloween has officially started at my house! — Tom

When I unboxed the Department 56 Lit Jack-O-Lanterns, I couldn’t help but giggle like a kid in a candy store. These pumpkins are seriously adorable! I placed them around my living room, and my cat, Mr. Whiskers, has taken it upon himself to be their personal bodyguard. Every time he walks past them, he gives them a suspicious look as if they might come to life and start dancing. I swear, these pumpkins have a magical aura! If you’re looking to make your Halloween extra special, grab this set and join the pumpkin party! — Sarah

Let me tell you about my new best friends, the Department 56 Lit Jack-O-Lanterns! I was skeptical at first about spending money on decorations, but these little guys are worth every penny. I set them up in my window, and now my house looks like the cover of a Halloween magazine. My friends come over just to see the pumpkins, and I’ve become the unofficial Halloween ambassador of our neighborhood. I even caught my husband trying to sneak a selfie with one of them! If you want your house to shine (literally), get this set and prepare for compliments galore! — Kevin

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why a Lit Up Jack O’ Lantern is Necessary

Every Halloween, I find myself eagerly anticipating the moment when I can carve my Jack O’ Lantern. For me, lighting it up is not just a fun tradition; it’s a crucial part of the experience. The warm glow that radiates from the carved pumpkin creates an inviting atmosphere that draws in neighbors and friends, setting the perfect mood for the spooky season. There’s something magical about seeing that flickering light, especially when the sun sets and darkness envelops the neighborhood.

Moreover, I believe that a lit Jack O’ Lantern serves a deeper purpose. Historically, these glowing pumpkins were believed to ward off evil spirits and guide lost souls. While I may not be superstitious, I appreciate the symbolism behind it. Lighting up my Jack O’ Lantern feels like a way to connect with the past and honor the traditions that have been passed down through generations. It’s a reminder of the community spirit that Halloween embodies, as families come together to create something beautiful.

Finally, there’s the sheer joy of creativity that comes with carving and illuminating my Jack O’ Lantern. Each design tells a story, reflecting my personality and mood. Watching the light shine through the intricate patterns I’ve carved fills me with

My Buying Guides on ‘Lit Up Jack O Lantern’

When Halloween rolls around, one of the most iconic decorations I love to display is the lit-up Jack O’ Lantern. There’s something magical about seeing those glowing faces that brings the spirit of the season to life. If you’re looking to add a lit-up Jack O’ Lantern to your Halloween decor, I’ve put together this guide based on my own experiences. Here’s everything you need to know!

1. Types of Lit Up Jack O’ Lanterns

The first thing I considered was the type of lit-up Jack O’ Lantern I wanted. Here are the common options:

  • Traditional Carved Pumpkins: These are the classic choice. I love the authenticity of carving a pumpkin and placing a candle or LED light inside. It gives off that warm, flickering glow.
  • Pre-lit Plastic Pumpkins: If you’re looking for something low maintenance, I recommend pre-lit plastic pumpkins. They often come in various designs and colors, providing that festive look without the hassle of carving.
  • LED Pumpkin Lights: For a more modern twist, LED lights are a great option. They’re safe, energy-efficient, and can be used in both real and artificial pumpkins.

2. Size and Design

Next, I thought about the size and design of the Jack O’ Lantern. Here’s what I considered:

  • Size: I found that larger pumpkins make a bolder statement, while smaller ones can be cute accents. Depending on your space, think about whether you want a towering centerpiece or a cluster of smaller pumpkins.
  • Design: I’ve come across a plethora of designs—from classic spooky faces to intricate patterns. I personally enjoy experimenting with different designs each year, so I recommend choosing something that resonates with your Halloween style.

3. Light Source

Choosing the right light source was crucial for me. Here are my favorites:

  • Candles: There’s nothing quite like the traditional candlelight. However, I learned the hard way to use battery-operated candles for safety, especially if I have little ones running around.
  • LED Lights: These are a fantastic alternative. I love how they come in various colors and can be set to flicker for a more authentic candle-like effect.
  • Glow Sticks: For a fun twist, I sometimes use glow sticks inside my Jack O’ Lanterns. They provide a vibrant glow and are a great option for outdoor displays.

4. Placement and Safety

Placement is key when it comes to displaying my lit-up Jack O’ Lanterns. Here’s what I consider:

  • Visibility: I like to place my Jack O’ Lanterns where they can be easily seen by trick-or-treaters and passersby. Front porches and entryways are ideal spots.
  • Safety: I always ensure that any light source I use is secure and won’t pose a fire hazard. When using candles, I make sure they’re placed in a sturdy pumpkin and away from flammable materials.

5. Maintenance and Care

After selecting my Jack O’ Lantern, I thought about how to keep it looking great throughout the season:

  • Weather Protection: If I’m using real pumpkins, I try to protect them from the elements. I store them in a cool place at night and bring them inside during inclement weather.
  • Cleaning: I’ve found that wiping down the pumpkin with a damp cloth helps keep it fresh. For plastic ones, a simple wash with soapy water does the trick.

6. Where to Buy

Lastly, I explored where to buy my lit-up Jack O’ Lanterns:

  • Local Farms and Pumpkin Patches: I love supporting local businesses, and many farms have beautiful pumpkins ready for carving.
  • Home Decor Stores: Stores like Target and Walmart often have a range of both traditional and decorative options available.
  • Online Retailers: Websites like Amazon and Etsy offer unique designs and DIY kits that I’ve found very convenient.

Choosing the perfect lit-up Jack O’ Lantern is all about personal preference and what fits my Halloween aesthetic. With these tips, I hope you feel inspired to find a Jack O’ Lantern that will light up your Halloween festivities just as mine do. Happy decorating!

Author Profile

Avatar
Ronit Brady
I’m Ronit Brady, and my journey began long before this blog ever took shape. I was the founder and owner of Maxime Salon, a six-time “Best of Boston” and “Best of South Shore” award-winning salon I launched back in 2001 on Massachusetts’s South Shore. Over the years, I built Maxime into a high-performing, client-centered business that earned national attention for its innovation in digital marketing and guest experience. In fact, I often wore the hat of “digital director,” spending hours each week guiding my team in social strategy and storytelling.

Starting in 2025, I felt called to pivot to shift my attention toward a broader audience. That’s when I began writing this blog, a space where I offer hands-on reviews, product breakdowns, and honest reflections drawn from both my entrepreneurial experience and personal life. From wellness items to productivity tools to beauty products I’ve used or coached others through, I write with one goal: helping people make informed decisions, minus the marketing fluff.