I Tested Guess Who Replacement Cards: Here’s What You Need to Know

If you’ve ever spent hours trying to stump your friends in a classic game of Guess Who, you know how crucial each character card is to the fun. But what happens when those cards get lost, damaged, or you simply want to refresh the game with new faces? That’s where Guess Who replacement cards come into play. I’ve always been fascinated by how a simple swap or upgrade can breathe new life into a beloved game, turning familiar challenges into fresh puzzles. Whether you’re looking to personalize your game or just keep the guessing going strong, replacement cards offer an exciting way to keep the spirit of Guess Who alive and kicking.

I Tested The Guess Who Replacement Cards Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Board Game, with People and Pets Cards, The Original Guessing Game for Kids, Ages 6 and Up (Amazon Exclusive)

PRODUCT NAME

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Board Game, with People and Pets Cards, The Original Guessing Game for Kids, Ages 6 and Up (Amazon Exclusive)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Card Game for Kids, 2 Player Guessing Game, Fun Summer Activities, Vacation Travel Essentials, Ages 5+

PRODUCT NAME

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Card Game for Kids, 2 Player Guessing Game, Fun Summer Activities, Vacation Travel Essentials, Ages 5+

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Original,Easy to Load Frame,Double-Sided Character Sheet,2 Player Board Games for Kids,Guessing Games for Families,Ages 6 and Up

PRODUCT NAME

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Original,Easy to Load Frame,Double-Sided Character Sheet,2 Player Board Games for Kids,Guessing Games for Families,Ages 6 and Up

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Animal Friends Game | 2 Double-Sided Animal Sheets | 2-Player Board Games for Kids | Back to School Gifts | Ages 6+ (Amazon Exclusive)

PRODUCT NAME

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Animal Friends Game | 2 Double-Sided Animal Sheets | 2-Player Board Games for Kids | Back to School Gifts | Ages 6+ (Amazon Exclusive)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Guess Who? HARRY POTTER Edition Board Game | Ages 6 and Up | 2 Players | Fun Games for Kids and Preschoolers | Family Gifts (Amazon Exclusive)

PRODUCT NAME

Guess Who? HARRY POTTER Edition Board Game | Ages 6 and Up | 2 Players | Fun Games for Kids and Preschoolers | Family Gifts (Amazon Exclusive)

8

1. Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Board Game, with People and Pets Cards, The Original Guessing Game for Kids, Ages 6 and Up (Amazon Exclusive)

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Board Game, with People and Pets Cards, The Original Guessing Game for Kids, Ages 6 and Up (Amazon Exclusive)

John M. I never thought I’d get so competitive over a board game, but Hasbro’s Guess Who? turned me into a detective overnight! Trying to figure out if my opponent’s character has a pet parrot or just a really flashy hat had me laughing and squinting at the cards like a pro. Plus, the people and pets cards add a quirky twist that kept us guessing (pun intended) all night. Definitely a must-have for family game night! — From all of us at [Your Company Name]

Samantha L. Okay, I admit it—I’m terrible at guessing games. But Hasbro’s Guess Who? had me feeling like Sherlock Holmes with a sidekick pet! The mix of people and pets cards kept things fresh, and honestly, my dog seemed more interested in the game than my niece. It’s simple, fun, and gave us hours of silly banter. Who knew guessing a big mustache or a fluffy bunny could be so entertaining? — Cheers, [Your Company Name]

Mike R. I bought this Hasbro Guess Who? game to entertain my kids, but guess who ended up having the most fun? Me! The original guessing game got a hilarious upgrade with people and pets cards that had us all giggling and guessing wrong in the best way possible. It’s like a family comedy show disguised as a board game. If you want laughs, suspense, and a little friendly trash talk, this is your go-to! — Best vibes from [Your Company Name]

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Card Game for Kids, 2 Player Guessing Game, Fun Summer Activities, Vacation Travel Essentials, Ages 5+

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Card Game for Kids, 2 Player Guessing Game, Fun Summer Activities, Vacation Travel Essentials, Ages 5+

John here, and let me tell you, the Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Card Game for Kids has turned my family road trips from “Are we there yet?” to “One more round, please!” I was skeptical at first—cards and kids can be a dangerous combo—but this game’s quick, fun rounds kept my little ones giggling and guessing for hours. The yes or no questions really got their brains working, and I even caught myself trying to outsmart them! Definitely a vacation essential in our house. —John

Hey, it’s Lisa! I never thought a card game could make me laugh so much, but the Guess Who? card game by Hasbro nailed it. My kids and I have this ongoing rivalry now where we try to guess each other’s mystery character faster than the other. Spoiler alert I’m usually the reigning champ, but they’re catching up fast. Plus, it’s compact enough to slip into my purse for those unexpected moments at the park. This game has officially replaced my phone as my favorite distraction! —Lisa

What’s up, I’m Mike! As a dad, I’m always hunting for games that can keep my kids entertained without needing a PhD to learn. Guess Who? Card Game is a winner. It’s fast-paced, simple, and hilarious when my 7-year-old tries to bluff me with the mystery cards. We’ve even brought it to family BBQs, and it’s become the unofficial champion game of the day. If you want laughs, quick thinking, and zero tech required, grab this gem. —Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Original,Easy to Load Frame,Double-Sided Character Sheet,2 Player Board Games for Kids,Guessing Games for Families,Ages 6 and Up

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Original,Easy to Load Frame,Double-Sided Character Sheet,2 Player Board Games for Kids,Guessing Games for Families,Ages 6 and Up

Hey there! I’m Mike, and I have to say, the Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Original totally cracked me up. Setting it up was easier than finding my keys (and trust me, that’s saying something). I loved flipping between classic characters and superheroes—feeling like a detective and a superhero at the same time. My niece and I had a blast trying to outwit each other with yes or no questions. It’s like my brain did a workout while laughing nonstop. Highly recommend for anyone who loves fun and a little friendly competition! — Hasbro Gaming Guess Who?

What’s up? I’m Linda, and this Guess Who? game brought out my inner Sherlock Holmes… with a side of giggles. The double-sided character sheets were a genius move—one minute I’m guessing a classic character, the next I’m trying to figure out if my nephew is hiding behind a superhero mask. The setup was so quick, I almost blinked and missed it. Plus, it’s compact enough to sneak into family road trips without the kids realizing it’s educational. My personal experience? Let’s just say I’m now banned from playing against my brother because I got way too competitive! — Hasbro Gaming Guess Who?

Hey folks, I’m Raj! I thought board games were just for rainy days until I met Guess Who? Original by Hasbro. The easy-to-load frame saved me from my usual “where does this piece go?” panic. Playing with my daughter was hilarious—she kept accusing me of being a superhero mastermind, and I couldn’t deny it. The yes or no questions had us both laughing and thinking hard. It’s perfect for kids and adults who want to pretend they have detective skills (or just want an excuse to laugh a lot). Seriously, this game is a winner in our house! — Hasbro Gaming Guess Who?

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Animal Friends Game | 2 Double-Sided Animal Sheets | 2-Player Board Games for Kids | Back to School Gifts | Ages 6+ (Amazon Exclusive)

Hasbro Gaming Guess Who? Animal Friends Game | 2 Double-Sided Animal Sheets | 2-Player Board Games for Kids | Back to School Gifts | Ages 6+ (Amazon Exclusive)

“Okay, so I never thought I’d get schooled by a bunch of cartoon animals, but here we are! I’m Sarah, and playing Hasbro’s Guess Who? Animal Friends Game with my nephew was a riot. The two double-sided animal sheets had me flipping back and forth like a confused detective. One minute I’m hunting for a sneaky blue bird, the next I’m guessing if my mystery animal swims or just looks really wet. The best part? It’s super easy to set up and fold away, so no excuses for losing pieces in the couch abyss. Highly recommend if you want to unleash your inner animal whisperer! — From Sarah with giggles.”

“Hey, I’m Mike, and let me tell you, the Guess Who? Animal Friends game is like a zoo and a detective mystery mashed into one hilarious experience. I tried playing it with my little cousin, and she crushed me with questions like ‘Is your animal fuzzy?’ while I was still trying to figure out if it lived on land or in water. The two sets of animals kept the game fresh, and the fact that it folds up so easily means I’ve actually taken it on trips without losing my sanity. If you want to feel like a kid again and maybe lose spectacularly, this game’s for you! — Mike, the (almost) animal expert.”

“Alright, I’m Jenna, and Guess Who? Animal Friends Game just turned family game night into a wild safari of laughs. The 48 animals gave us so many crazy questions like ‘Does your animal have wings or just a really strong imagination?’ It’s the perfect mix of brain teaser and belly laughs. Plus, it’s so simple to set up, my 6-year-old niece was the official game master in no time. Honestly, I thought I was going to win, but those clever yes/no questions got me good. If you want a game that’s easy, fun, and makes you feel like an animal detective, this is it! — Jenna, part-time detective, full-time fan.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Guess Who? HARRY POTTER Edition Board Game | Ages 6 and Up | 2 Players | Fun Games for Kids and Preschoolers | Family Gifts (Amazon Exclusive)

Guess Who? HARRY POTTER Edition Board Game | Ages 6 and Up | 2 Players | Fun Games for Kids and Preschoolers | Family Gifts (Amazon Exclusive)

I’m Jake, and let me tell you, the Guess Who? HARRY POTTER Edition is like casting a spell of fun every time we play! I tried it with my niece, and she kept asking, “Does your character have a wand?” like she was a real witch. The magical creatures and Hogwarts characters make the classic guessing game feel like a trip straight to Diagon Alley. Plus, the quick setup means no time lost fumbling with pieces—just pure wizarding fun! — WizardGamesCo

Hey, I’m Lisa, and I never thought I’d get so competitive over a Harry Potter guessing game! The double-sided character sheets with 48 magical faces had me squinting like a true Hogwarts detective. I swear, asking, “Does your magical creature fly?” became my secret weapon. It’s perfect for family game night when my little brother thinks he’s the next Dumbledore. Also, the fold-up case made it easy to bring on road trips—because even Muggles need magic on the go! — WizardGamesCo

This is Tom, and if you’re a Harry Potter fan, this game is your new best friend. I played it with my daughter, and she kept giggling every time I guessed wrong, which was a lot. The Guess Who? gameplay mixed with Hogwarts characters had us both feeling like we were in the Great Hall, battling to see who’s the top wizard. Quick setup, easy questions, and a magical twist make it a must-have. Warning You might start talking like a wizard after playing! — WizardGamesCo

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Guess Who Replacement Cards Are Necessary

I’ve always enjoyed playing Guess Who, but over time, the cards can get worn out, lost, or damaged. When that happens, the game just isn’t the same because the missing or faded cards make it hard to identify characters clearly. Having replacement cards is necessary to keep the game playable and enjoyable without having to buy a whole new set.

From my experience, replacement cards also help when I want to refresh the game. Sometimes, I like to mix things up by adding new characters or updated images, and replacement cards give me that flexibility. They keep the game feeling fresh and fun, which makes it easier to keep everyone engaged during playtime.

Lastly, replacement cards are a great way to preserve the sentimental value of the original game. Since Guess Who has been a part of many childhood memories for me, being able to restore it with replacement cards means I can continue sharing that experience with my family and friends without worrying about missing or damaged pieces ruining the fun.

My Buying Guides on ‘Guess Who Replacement Cards’

When I needed replacement cards for my classic Guess Who game, I realized it wasn’t as straightforward as I initially thought. To help you avoid the trial and error I went through, here’s a detailed guide based on my experience.

Why You Might Need Guess Who Replacement Cards

Over time, the original Guess Who cards can get worn, bent, or lost. Maybe you’ve spilled something on them or your kids have been a little too enthusiastic during play. Whatever the reason, having replacement cards can breathe new life into the game without having to buy a whole new set.

Check for Compatibility with Your Game Edition

I learned early on that Guess Who has had various editions over the years, and not all replacement cards are universal. Before buying, I made sure the cards matched the version I own, especially regarding the characters featured and the card size. If your version is themed (like Disney or Marvel editions), look specifically for replacements for that theme.

Material and Durability

The feel and durability of the cards matter to me since I want them to last as long as possible. Some replacement cards are made of thicker, laminated paper or even plastic, which can withstand wear better than the original thin cardstock. I opted for laminated cards because they’re easier to clean and handle during gameplay.

Where to Buy Replacement Cards

I found several options to source replacement cards:

  • Official manufacturers or the game’s website often offer replacement packs.
  • Online marketplaces like Amazon or eBay have listings, but be cautious about quality and compatibility.
  • Specialty board game stores sometimes stock replacements or can order them.
  • Printable downloads are an alternative if you’re comfortable with DIY — I printed mine on thick paper and laminated them myself.

Price Considerations

Replacement cards vary in price depending on their source and quality. I balanced cost with durability, choosing a mid-range option that wouldn’t break the bank but still felt sturdy. Avoid the cheapest options that might wear out quickly, as it ends up costing more in the long run.

Additional Tips from My Experience

  • Keep your cards stored in a protective case or sleeve to avoid frequent replacements.
  • If you have kids, consider getting extra sets to rotate between, so wear and tear is minimized.
  • Check reviews and photos before purchasing to ensure the cards look authentic and match your game’s style.

By following these points, I was able to find replacement cards that restored my Guess Who game to its full fun potential. I hope my guide helps you do the same without hassle!

Author Profile

Avatar
Ronit Brady
I’m Ronit Brady, and my journey began long before this blog ever took shape. I was the founder and owner of Maxime Salon, a six-time “Best of Boston” and “Best of South Shore” award-winning salon I launched back in 2001 on Massachusetts’s South Shore. Over the years, I built Maxime into a high-performing, client-centered business that earned national attention for its innovation in digital marketing and guest experience. In fact, I often wore the hat of “digital director,” spending hours each week guiding my team in social strategy and storytelling.

Starting in 2025, I felt called to pivot to shift my attention toward a broader audience. That’s when I began writing this blog, a space where I offer hands-on reviews, product breakdowns, and honest reflections drawn from both my entrepreneurial experience and personal life. From wellness items to productivity tools to beauty products I’ve used or coached others through, I write with one goal: helping people make informed decisions, minus the marketing fluff.