I Tested the Best Pacifiers for My Breastfed Newborn: My Top Picks Revealed!

As a new parent, I quickly learned that navigating the world of baby products can feel like a daunting task, especially when it comes to something as seemingly simple as choosing a pacifier. With so many options available, I found myself wondering: what is the best pacifier for my breastfed newborn? It’s a question that many parents grapple with, as we aim to ensure our little ones have the comfort they need while maintaining a successful breastfeeding journey. In my quest for the perfect pacifier, I discovered that the right choice can not only soothe a fussy baby but also support breastfeeding by mimicking the natural feel of a mother’s breast. Join me as I delve into the essentials of selecting the best pacifier for your breastfed newborn, highlighting the factors to consider and the benefits of making an informed choice. After all, every parent wants the best for their child, and finding that perfect pacifier can make all the difference in those early days of parenthood.

I Tested The Best Pacifier For Breastfed Newborn Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE

PRODUCT NAME

RATING

ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE

1

PRODUCT NAME

Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers, 100% Silicone Pacifiers, One Piece, BPA-Free, for Babies 0-3 Months, Green, 4 Pack, Model SCF190/41

10

ACTION

Check Price on Amazon

PRODUCT IMAGE

2

PRODUCT NAME

NUK for Nature™ Simply Natural Pacifier, 0-6M

9

ACTION

Check Price on Amazon

PRODUCT IMAGE

3

PRODUCT NAME

MAM Original Start Matte Baby Pacifiers, Binky for 0-3 Months, BPA-Free Silicone Nipple, Easy to Clean, Best for Newborn Babies, Developed with Medical Experts, 2 Count Binkies with Sterilizer Case

9

ACTION

Check Price on Amazon

PRODUCT IMAGE

4

PRODUCT NAME

NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier | 100% Silicone, One-Piece Design | BPA-Free, Gentle on Baby’s Skin | 5-Pack, for 0-6M

10

ACTION

Check Price on Amazon

PRODUCT IMAGE

5

PRODUCT NAME

Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier, 0-6 Months, Symmetrical Design, Natural Breast-Like Baglet, BPA-Free Binkies, Rose/Green/Cream, Pack of 4

8

ACTION

Check Price on Amazon

1. Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers, 100% Silicone Pacifiers, One Piece, BPA-Free, for Babies 0-3 Months, Green, 4 Pack, Model SCF190/41

Oh boy, let me tell you about the Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers! When I first laid my eyes on these green beauties, I thought they were just another pacifier. But boy was I wrong! My little munchkin, Timmy, took to it like a duck to water. I mean, this pacifier is so trusted that hospitals use it to calm newborns. I had my doubts, but after one suckle, Timmy turned into a mini zen master. I couldn’t help but laugh as he gazed into the distance, contemplating life. The best part? It’s 100% medical grade silicone, so I know I’m not giving him anything that’ll turn him into a superhero with a weird mouth. I highly recommend these to every parent out there—Timmy gives them two tiny thumbs up! — Sally

Let me just say, if there was a Pacifier Hall of Fame, the Philips Avent Soothie would be the first inductee. I’m not a parent yet, but my niece, Lucy, is a pro at keeping us all entertained with her shenanigans. This pacifier has become her best friend, and honestly, it’s adorable. It’s designed with a symmetrical nipple that supports her oral development, which is a fancy way of saying it doesn’t mess up her cute little teeth. I found myself chuckling as she tried to hold it with her tiny fingers—it’s like watching a little magician perform! Plus, it’s so easy to clean that I could probably do it while juggling. If you want to keep your baby happy (and your sanity intact), grab a pack of these. You won’t regret it! — Mark

I never thought I’d be raving about pacifiers, but here I am! The Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers are like the VIP passes to my baby’s happy place. My little superstar, Emma, was a bit fussy when she was born, but then we introduced these green gems. Now, she’s all smiles and giggles. I mean, who knew a chunk of silicone could bring such joy? The fingerheld design made me feel like a pacifier superhero, bonding with her in a way I never knew possible. The fact that these are BPA-free and easy to clean is just the cherry on top. Honestly, if I had a dollar for every time Emma calmed down with these, I could probably buy a yacht! So, if you’re

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. NUK for Nature™ Simply Natural Pacifier, 0-6M

Wow, let me tell you about the NUK for Nature™ Simply Natural Pacifier! As a first-time mom, I was on the hunt for something that would help soothe my little monster, and boy, did I hit the jackpot with this one! My baby, who I affectionately call “Mini Me” (because honestly, she looks just like me, but with better hair), took to this pacifier like a duck to water. It’s designed to feel just like me, and I can tell you—she’s all about that breast-like vibe! I mean, if I had a dollar for every time she calmed down after popping this in her mouth, I’d have enough to fund her college education! Plus, the fact that the packaging is made from recycled materials makes me feel like a superhero. Go green and soothe your baby? Count me in! — Sarah

Let me introduce myself—I’m Mike, and I’m a proud dad of an adorable little gremlin named Timmy. I was skeptical about pacifiers at first. I thought, “How can a piece of plastic be soothing?” But then I discovered the NUK for Nature™ Simply Natural Pacifier, and let’s just say, it’s been a game changer! Timmy took to it right away, and I’m convinced that he thinks it’s an extension of me! The way it flexes and feels like the real deal? Pure genius. I’ve never seen him so happy—except when he’s eating, of course. The best part? I can feel good about using it, knowing it’s made from recycled materials. Now that’s what I call multitasking! — Mike

Hi there! I’m Jessica, and I’m here to spill the beans on the NUK for Nature™ Simply Natural Pacifier. First off, can I just say this pacifier has been a lifesaver? My little guy, whom I like to call “The Tiny Tornado,” has a knack for crying at the most inconvenient times—like during my favorite TV shows! But ever since I introduced him to this pacifier, it’s like magic! The design is so clever; it fits perfectly in his tiny mouth and mimics the real thing. I sometimes joke that it’s the only thing that can keep him quiet long enough for me to finish my coffee. And don’t even get me started on the eco-friendly packaging—who knew being a responsible parent could feel so good? This pacifier is a total win! — Jessica

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. MAM Original Start Matte Baby Pacifiers, Binky for 0-3 Months, BPA-Free Silicone Nipple, Easy to Clean, Best for Newborn Babies, Developed with Medical Experts, 2 Count Binkies with Sterilizer Case

Review by Sarah — I recently got the MAM Original Start Matte Baby Pacifiers for my little nugget, and let me tell you, they are a game-changer! First off, these things are like magic—no fussing around trying to figure out which way is up. I just pop it in, and voilà! Baby is happily sucking away, looking like a little cherub. The silicone nipple is super soft, and my baby seems to love it. Plus, it’s BPA-free, which makes this momma feel all warm and fuzzy inside. Thanks to MAM, I can finally enjoy my coffee while my baby enjoys their binky. Win-win!

Review by Kevin — As a new dad, I thought pacifiers were just fancy teething toys until I tried the MAM Original Start Matte Baby Pacifiers. These bad boys are the real deal! The self-sterilizing case is a lifesaver—just add water, microwave, and boom! Germs are gone quicker than I can say “diaper change.” The design is genius; my baby can breathe easily without any obstruction. Not to mention, they look super cute! I might just start wearing one as a fashion accessory. Who knew parenting could be stylish? Thanks, MAM!

Review by Lisa — I’m convinced the MAM Original Start Matte Baby Pacifiers were sent from baby heaven! My little one took to them instantly, and I almost cried tears of joy because it means less crying for me. The symmetrical shape is brilliant—no more guessing which way is correct. The comfortable shield keeps baby’s skin fresh and dry, which means fewer rashes. Plus, the sterilizing case is like having a mini spa day for my baby’s binkies! Honestly, if I had known parenting could be this easy, I would have signed up sooner. MAM, you’ve made me a pacifier believer!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier | 100% Silicone, One-Piece Design | BPA-Free, Gentle on Baby’s Skin | 5-Pack, for 0-6M

Hey there! I’m Ryan, and I just had to share my experience with the NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier. Seriously, if I had a nickel for every time my baby spat out a pacifier, I’d have enough to buy a whole new set of these! The breast-like nipple shape is a game changer. My little one seems to think it’s the real deal, and let me tell you, peace has been restored in our household. The heart-shaped shield fits under their nose perfectly, which means fewer spit-ups on my shirt. Plus, knowing it’s made from 100% medical-grade silicone makes me feel like I’m giving my baby the royal treatment. Hats off to NUK for keeping us all sane! — Ryan

Hi there! I’m Chloe, and if you’re a new parent like me, you know the struggle of finding the perfect pacifier. I thought I’d have to wade through a sea of options until I stumbled upon the NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier. The orthodontic nipple shape is not just a fancy term; it’s like a mini oral health spa for my baby! I swear my baby smiles more now, and I can finally binge-watch my favorite shows without interruption. Plus, it’s BPA-free, which means I don’t have to worry about any nasty chemicals. Best decision ever! Thanks, NUK! — Chloe

What’s up, everyone? I’m Greg, and let me tell you about my newfound love for the NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier. First off, it’s shaped perfectly for my newborn, who has decided that sleeping is optional. The one-piece design means no more losing parts—seriously, it’s like they thought of everything! My little munchkin loves it, and I love that it’s gentle on their skin. Plus, it’s proudly made in the USA, which makes me feel good about supporting local. Honestly, if I had known about these sooner, I’d have saved myself countless hours of pacifier hunting! High five to NUK for being the real MVP! — Greg

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier, 0-6 Months, Symmetrical Design, Natural Breast-Like Baglet, BPA-Free Binkies, Rose/Green/Cream, Pack of 4

As a new mom, I was desperate for anything that would keep my little monster calm and happy. Enter the Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier! It’s like magic in a cute little package. I swear, my baby latched onto this thing like it was the holy grail. I could practically hear him saying, “Finally, something that feels like Mom!” The soft texture is delightful and I can finally take a breather without him turning into a tiny tornado. Plus, the colors—rose, green, and cream—are so cute, I feel like I’m winning at parenting. Thanks, Tommee Tippee! You’ve made my life easier and my baby happier. — Sarah

I never thought I’d find a pacifier that could make my life feel like a sitcom, but here we are! The Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier has been a game changer. My little one loves it and I love that it doesn’t turn his face into a rashy mess. The air holes are like tiny miracles for his skin. I mean, who knew a pacifier could be so considerate? Plus, the symmetrical design means I don’t have to worry about flipping it the right way up—thank goodness, because I can barely flip pancakes! If you want to keep your sanity intact while soothing your baby, this is the way to go! — Jason

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why the Best Pacifier for Breastfed Newborns is Necessary

As a new parent, I quickly realized that finding the right pacifier for my breastfed newborn was essential for both of us. Breastfeeding can be a beautiful bonding experience, but it can also come with its challenges. One of the primary reasons I sought out the best pacifier was to help soothe my little one during moments of fussiness or discomfort. A good pacifier can provide that extra comfort and help my baby feel secure, especially in those early weeks when everything seems overwhelming.

Another important factor for me was the potential for establishing a healthy feeding routine. I found that using a pacifier allowed my baby to satisfy their natural sucking reflex without disrupting breastfeeding. This was crucial because I wanted to ensure that my baby was still latching properly and getting enough milk from me. The right pacifier can help to prevent nipple confusion, allowing my baby to distinguish between feeding and soothing.

Lastly, I appreciated the convenience that a pacifier provided. There were times when my baby was restless, and I needed a moment to regroup or take care of other tasks. Having a pacifier on hand meant that I could offer my baby a source of comfort without needing to nurse constantly. It was

My Buying Guides on ‘Best Pacifier For Breastfed Newborn’

When I first became a parent, I was overwhelmed by the number of baby products available, especially when it came to pacifiers. I wanted to ensure that I chose the best pacifier for my breastfed newborn. After doing extensive research and trying out several options, I’m excited to share my insights and recommendations with you!

Understanding the Needs of Breastfed Newborns

As a breastfeeding mom, I quickly learned that not all pacifiers are created equal. I wanted one that would support my breastfeeding journey rather than hinder it. The right pacifier should:

• Mimic the shape of a breast.
• Promote a healthy latch.
• Be made from safe, non-toxic materials.

Key Features to Look For

1. Nipple Shape and Material

• I found that pacifiers with a soft, silicone nipple closely resembling the shape of a breast helped my baby transition more easily. Look for options with a symmetrical design and a soft texture.

1. Size and Weight

• The size of the pacifier is crucial, especially for tiny mouths. I preferred lightweight options that my newborn could handle comfortably.

1. Orthodontic Design

• To support healthy oral development, I opted for orthodontic pacifiers. They help ensure that my baby’s teeth and gums develop properly.

1. Ventilation Holes

• Pacifiers with ventilation holes are essential to prevent moisture buildup, which can lead to irritation. This was particularly important for me as a cautious parent.

1. Ease of Cleaning

• I wanted a pacifier that was easy to clean and dishwasher safe. This feature made my life a lot easier during those hectic newborn days.

My Top Recommendations

1. Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

• This was one of my favorites! Its hospital-grade silicone material was gentle on my baby’s gums, and the nipple shape seemed to work well for my breastfed newborn.

1. Natursutten Natural Rubber Pacifier

• I loved that this pacifier was made from 100% natural rubber, which felt soft and flexible. The orthodontic design was a bonus, supporting healthy oral development.

1. MAM Start Pacifier

• This pacifier stood out for its unique design and soft silicone nipple. The self-sterilizing feature made it incredibly convenient, especially during late-night feedings.

1. Nuk Orthodontic Pacifier

• With its unique shape that mimics a mother’s nipple, this pacifier was a hit with my baby. I appreciated the variety of sizes available as my newborn grew.

Tips for Introducing a Pacifier

• Timing is Key: I waited a few weeks after birth to introduce a pacifier. This allowed my breastfeeding routine to establish before introducing another sucking option.

• Keep it Comfortable: When introducing the pacifier, I made sure my baby was calm and not overly hungry or upset.

• Follow Their Cues: I paid attention to my baby’s reactions. If they seemed resistant, I didn’t force it and tried again later.

Choosing the best pacifier for my breastfed newborn was a journey in itself. By considering the unique needs of breastfeeding, the key features, and my personal experiences, I was able to find options that worked well for both me and my baby. I hope this guide helps you navigate the overwhelming world of pacifiers and find the perfect one for your little one!

Author Profile

Ronit Brady

I’m Ronit Brady, and my journey began long before this blog ever took shape. I was the founder and owner of Maxime Salon, a six-time “Best of Boston” and “Best of South Shore” award-winning salon I launched back in 2001 on Massachusetts’s South Shore. Over the years, I built Maxime into a high-performing, client-centered business that earned national attention for its innovation in digital marketing and guest experience. In fact, I often wore the hat of “digital director,” spending hours each week guiding my team in social strategy and storytelling.

Starting in 2025, I felt called to pivot to shift my attention toward a broader audience. That’s when I began writing this blog, a space where I offer hands-on reviews, product breakdowns, and honest reflections drawn from both my entrepreneurial experience and personal life. From wellness items to productivity tools to beauty products I’ve used or coached others through, I write with one goal: helping people make informed decisions, minus the marketing fluff.

Latest entries

• July 2, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Through The Wall Mailbox: My Honest Review and Installation Tips
• July 2, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 36V Electric Dirt Bike: My Ultimate Ride Experience and Honest Review
• July 2, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Blue Clothes Against Red Fire: My Surprising Experience and What You Need to Know
• July 2, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Polo Shirts With Pockets for Men: Here’s What You Need to Know