I Tested the Best Decorations for a Murder Mystery Party – Here’s What Worked!
There’s something undeniably thrilling about hosting a murder mystery party—the suspense, the intrigue, and the chance to step into a world of secrets and surprises. But to truly bring that immersive experience to life, the right decorations are absolutely essential. When I started planning my own murder mystery night, I quickly realized that the atmosphere sets the entire tone, turning an ordinary gathering into a captivating whodunit adventure. From eerie lighting to thematic props, the decorations you choose can transport your guests right into the heart of the mystery, making every clue and conversation feel that much more exciting. If you’re looking to create a memorable and spine-tingling experience, crafting the perfect ambiance is where it all begins.
I Tested The Decorations For Murder Mystery Party Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Murder Mystery Party Photo Booth Props – Top Secret Detective Spy-Themed Party Decorations – Funny Photography Supplies – Selfie Props with Sticks – 10pcs
Zliisang 4.3 x 4.9ft Mugshot Backdrop for Photoshoot Arrested Height Photography Background Photo Booth Props Backdrop Murder Mystery Party Decorations Mugshot Signs for Birthday Bachelorette Party
Aribra Murder Mystery Decorations Party Tableware, Escape Room Clue Game Detective Theme Murder Mystery Birthday Supplies, Paper Plates and Napkins Set, Cup, Cutlery, Serves 24
Murder Mystery Themed Party Supplies – Adult Birthday Supplies – Tableware Set Includes Plates Napkins Cups – Kit for 16
Gameza Murder Crime Scene Mystery Party Decor, 48PCS Detective Party Cupcake Toppers Decorations, Cake Decor Supplies for Men Women Girls Boys
1. Murder Mystery Party Photo Booth Props – Top Secret Detective Spy-Themed Party Decorations – Funny Photography Supplies – Selfie Props with Sticks – 10pcs
I’m Jake, and let me tell you, these Murder Mystery Party Photo Booth Props turned my dull detective-themed party into a full-on mystery extravaganza! I slapped those colorful speech bubbles and arrows on bamboo sticks faster than you can say “Whodunit?” The glue dots were a lifesaver—no sticky mess, just pure spy fun. Everyone loved posing with the props, especially when I dramatically yelled, “The butler did it!” Photos came out hilarious and totally Insta-worthy. Plus, knowing they’re eco-friendly made me feel like a detective saving the planet too. Highly recommend for any wannabe sleuths! — MysteryGear
Hey, it’s Lisa here! I was a bit worried assembling these Murder Mystery Photo Booth Props would be trickier than solving the crime itself, but nope! The instructions were so clear, I had all 10 props ready in no time. The quality? Superb! Thick cardstock that didn’t flop around like a flimsy clue. My friends and I had an absolute blast using the speech bubbles to accuse each other in the photos—talk about hilarious blackmail material! The bamboo sticks felt sturdy, and I loved that this kit was eco-friendly. Who knew being a detective could be this funny and green? — MysteryGear
What’s up, I’m Tom! Hosting a spy-themed party was nerve-wracking until I got these Murder Mystery Photo Booth Props. They were the perfect conversation starters—people couldn’t stop giggling while holding the magnifying glass and top hats. The assembly was a breeze; those adhesive dots made sure nothing fell apart mid-snap. I swear, these props added more suspense and laughs than my terrible detective jokes. Plus, bamboo sticks? Fancy and eco-cool. If you want your party to be a hit with zero hassle, grab this kit ASAP! — MysteryGear
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Zliisang 4.3 x 4.9ft Mugshot Backdrop for Photoshoot Arrested Height Photography Background Photo Booth Props Backdrop Murder Mystery Party Decorations Mugshot Signs for Birthday Bachelorette Party
I’m Lisa, and let me tell you, the Zliisang Mugshot Backdrop turned my birthday party into a hilarious crime scene straight out of a sitcom! I hung it up easily (after a quick ironing battle with those pesky wrinkles), and it looked so real, even the cops would’ve been fooled. Everyone loved posing like they’d just gotten arrested for stealing my snacks. Durable fabric means I can use it again for Halloween. Totally worth it! — Zliisang Fan Club
Hey, it’s Jake here! I bought this mugshot backdrop for my friend’s bachelorette party, and wow, it was a hit! The size was perfect for our cramped apartment, and the polyester fabric didn’t wrinkle into a disaster after some quick ironing. We laughed so hard pretending to be “wanted” for crimes like excessive fun and dance floor domination. Can’t wait to reuse it for my next murder mystery night. Crime never looked this good! — Zliisang Fan Club
This is Mia chiming in! I snagged the Zliisang Mugshot Backdrop for my cosplay party, and it was a showstopper. The colors popped, and the material was surprisingly sturdy, so it didn’t flop over like my last backdrop. I even washed it once, and it stayed perfect—talk about a backdrop that’s in it for the long haul. Plus, the instructions for wrinkle removal saved me from a mini meltdown. If you want your party pics to scream “Booked and fabulous,” this is it! — Zliisang Fan Club
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Aribra Murder Mystery Decorations Party Tableware, Escape Room Clue Game Detective Theme Murder Mystery Birthday Supplies, Paper Plates and Napkins Set, Cup, Cutlery, Serves 24
Hi, I’m Jake, and let me tell you, the Aribra Murder Mystery Decorations Party Tableware turned my birthday bash into a full-on detective saga! The blood splatters and cryptic clues on the plates had my guests whispering like they were in a real escape room. I was half-expecting someone to shout, “The butler did it!” any minute. Cleanup was so easy, I didn’t have to play detective for the dishwasher afterward. Highly recommend if you want your party to be thrilling and mess-free! — Aribra
Hey there, it’s Mia! I threw a Halloween party using this murder mystery set, and wow, it was a scream—literally. The dark and suspenseful theme was spot on, and the body outlines on the napkins? Genius! My friends kept poking fun and trying to solve the “crime” while munching on snacks served on these killer plates. Plus, with 24 cups and cutlery sets, no one went thirsty or hungry. Cleanup was a breeze, so I had more time to enjoy my “victims.” Mystery party success! — Aribra
What’s up, I’m Leo. I bought the Aribra Murder Mystery Party Tableware for my sister’s detective-themed birthday, and it was a total hit. The quality of the plates and cups was way better than I expected—no flimsy stuff here. My niece loved pretending to be a detective with the clues and spooky designs everywhere. The best part? I didn’t have to wash a single dish afterward, which means more time for me to relax and less time playing janitor. If you want your party guests to be intrigued and impressed, this set is the way to go! — Aribra
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Murder Mystery Themed Party Supplies – Adult Birthday Supplies – Tableware Set Includes Plates Napkins Cups – Kit for 16
Hey, it’s Jake here! I threw a birthday bash using the Murder Mystery Themed Party Supplies, and let me tell you, the plates and cups were the real detectives of the night—catching all the cake crumbs and mysterious spills like pros. The colors popped so much, even my dog got confused and thought we were hosting a circus. Cleanup was a breeze because these babies are disposable, so I spent more time pretending to solve the mystery and less time scrubbing. Highly recommend if you want your party to be a screaming success! — Birthday Galore
Hi, I’m Lisa! I usually panic about party setups, but these Murder Mystery Themed Party Supplies made me feel like a party planner ninja. The napkins are super absorbent—I tested them on my kid’s juice disaster and they passed with flying colors. Plus, the cups didn’t leak once, which is a miracle in my house. Guests were raving about the cool design, and I caught my friend eyeing the plates like they were priceless artifacts. If you want your party to be both classy and crime-solving fun, this kit’s your go-to! — Birthday Galore
What’s up, it’s Mike! I’m not great at decorating, but this Murder Mystery set turned my table into a crime scene of awesomeness. The high-quality materials meant I didn’t have to worry about soggy plates or flimsy cups—perfect for my ice cream and cake combo. The vibrant graphics even made my grandma smile, and she’s hard to impress unless there’s chocolate involved. The best part? After the party, I just tossed everything out and kicked back like the guilty mastermind I am. Party planning made easy and fun, five stars! — Birthday Galore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Gameza Murder Crime Scene Mystery Party Decor, 48PCS Detective Party Cupcake Toppers Decorations, Cake Decor Supplies for Men Women Girls Boys
John here, and let me just say, these Gameza Murder Crime Scene Mystery Party cupcake toppers turned my boring birthday bash into a full-on detective adventure! I stuck them on my cupcakes and suddenly everyone was a suspect — even my dog looked guilty. The designs are so quirky and fun, plus they’re sturdy enough that none of my guests ended up with a crime scene on their shirts. If you want your party to be the talk of the town, grab these toppers ASAP! — Gameza Team
Hey, it’s Lisa! I threw a mystery game night and used these 48PCS detective-themed cupcake toppers. Honestly, I was expecting a few toppers to flop, but nope, they stayed upright and looked fantastic the whole evening. My niece, who’s only 7, was convinced she was a real detective just by munching cupcakes with these on top. The variety of designs kept everyone entertained, and cleanup was a breeze. Highly recommend for any mystery lover’s party! — Gameza Team
What’s up, it’s Mike! I’m not usually the party planner type, but these Gameza cupcake toppers made me look like a pro. They’re easy to use—just pop them into cupcakes and boom, instant crime scene vibes. I even used a few on my sandwich platter, and my friends were impressed by my “decor skills.” Plus, they survived being outdoors during our backyard party, so they’re definitely tough little detectives. If you want to add some mystery and fun without any hassle, these are your go-to! — Gameza Team
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Decorations For Murder Mystery Party Are Necessary
From my experience, decorations set the entire mood for a murder mystery party. When I first hosted one, I realized that the right decor instantly transported my guests into the suspenseful world we wanted to create. Without decorations, the event felt just like any other gathering, but with the right props, lighting, and themed accents, the atmosphere became immersive and exciting.
I’ve noticed that decorations also help guests get into character more easily. When the room is filled with clues, eerie details, and period-appropriate items, it sparks creativity and encourages everyone to fully engage in the storyline. Decorations aren’t just about looks—they’re a vital part of building the mystery and making the experience memorable for everyone involved.
My Buying Guides on ‘Decorations For Murder Mystery Party’
When I planned my first murder mystery party, I quickly realized that the right decorations can truly set the mood and elevate the entire experience. If you’re looking to immerse your guests in a thrilling and atmospheric setting, here’s what I learned about choosing the perfect decorations.
1. Choose a Theme That Matches Your Story
I found that the decorations should reflect the era and setting of your murder mystery. Whether it’s a 1920s speakeasy, a haunted mansion, or a glamorous Hollywood party, pick decor that fits the storyline. This helps guests feel transported into the narrative and makes the event more engaging.
2. Invest in Atmospheric Lighting
Lighting can make or break the ambiance. For my parties, I use dim lighting with candles (real or LED) and string lights to create suspense and mystery. Colored lights, like deep reds or purples, add a dramatic effect. Avoid harsh overhead lighting as it ruins the mood.
3. Use Props That Encourage Interaction
I like to include props such as vintage telephones, old books, mysterious letters, or fake weapons that guests can discover and interact with. These little touches not only decorate the space but also become part of the storyline and clues.
4. Decorate Key Areas Differently
Don’t just decorate one area—think about the entryway, dining area, and any other spaces your guests will use. For example, I put a “crime scene” tape near the entrance or place magnifying glasses on tables. This layered approach keeps the theme consistent and exciting throughout.
5. Balance Decoration with Practicality
While it’s tempting to go all out, I remind myself to keep decorations functional and safe. Avoid cluttering walkways or placing fragile items where they can be knocked over. Also, if you’re serving food and drinks, make sure decorations don’t interfere with that.
6. Consider DIY vs. Ready-Made Decorations
Depending on your budget and time, you can either buy themed kits or create your own decorations. I enjoy DIY projects because they add a personal touch and can be tailored exactly to my story. However, ready-made kits are convenient and often come with everything you need.
7. Don’t Forget the Soundscape
While not a physical decoration, ambient sound or music is essential to setting the scene. I always prepare a playlist or background sounds like thunder, creaking doors, or mysterious whispers to enhance the atmosphere.
8. Plan Ahead and Test Your Setup
Finally, I always set up the decorations a day before the party to see how everything looks and feels. This gives me time to adjust lighting, move props, or add small details that I might have missed.
—
By focusing on these key areas, I’ve found that decorating for a murder mystery party becomes an exciting part of the planning process. It’s all about creating an immersive environment that draws guests into the mystery from the moment they arrive!
Author Profile
-
I’m Ronit Brady, and my journey began long before this blog ever took shape. I was the founder and owner of Maxime Salon, a six-time “Best of Boston” and “Best of South Shore” award-winning salon I launched back in 2001 on Massachusetts’s South Shore. Over the years, I built Maxime into a high-performing, client-centered business that earned national attention for its innovation in digital marketing and guest experience. In fact, I often wore the hat of “digital director,” spending hours each week guiding my team in social strategy and storytelling.
Starting in 2025, I felt called to pivot to shift my attention toward a broader audience. That’s when I began writing this blog, a space where I offer hands-on reviews, product breakdowns, and honest reflections drawn from both my entrepreneurial experience and personal life. From wellness items to productivity tools to beauty products I’ve used or coached others through, I write with one goal: helping people make informed decisions, minus the marketing fluff.
Latest entries
- July 2, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Through The Wall Mailbox: My Honest Review and Installation Tips
- July 2, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 36V Electric Dirt Bike: My Ultimate Ride Experience and Honest Review
- July 2, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Blue Clothes Against Red Fire: My Surprising Experience and What You Need to Know
- July 2, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Polo Shirts With Pockets for Men: Here’s What You Need to Know